Tackling Gender Bias in Machine Translation: Why Human Translators Are Still Essential

By: Universal Language Service

In the world of international communication, machine translation (MT) has made it easier than ever before to communicate across different languages. Whether you’re traveling, working, or just chatting with a colleague from another country, MT tools such as Google Translate have become the norm. However, these tools aren’t always accurate. One major issue is gender bias in translation.

What is Gender Bias in Machine Translation?

Gender bias in machine translation happens when the system/software makes assumptions about gender that aren’t based on the actual text. This can lead to translations that reinforce stereotypes or just aren’t accurate. The problem comes from the fact that these systems are trained on huge amounts of text, which include the biases that already exist in modern society. So, when the machine doesn’t have enough of the required context, it might default to using male pronouns or terms even when the gender is unknown or should be neutral.

Example of Gender Bias

Here is one simple example:

  • “The doctor gave the patient their prescription.”

When translated into Spanish, which uses gendered nouns and pronouns, a biased translation would look something like this:

  • “El doctor le dio la receta al paciente.”
    • Translation: “The (male) doctor gave the prescription to the (male) patient.”

In this translation, the machine assumed both the doctor and the patient were male, even though the original wording never specified their genders. This kind of mistake can lead to misunderstandings which reinforces outdated stereotypes.

How Apple and USC Are Working to Fix This

To combat this common issue, researchers at Apple and the University of Southern California (USC) have decided on a new approach when it comes to translation. Instead of just guessing the gender, their system identifies when there’s gender ambiguity and offers multiple translation options.

For example, the sentence “The doctor gave the patient their prescription” could be translated into Spanish in several ways:

  1. “El doctor le dio la receta al paciente.” (Male doctor, male patient)
  2. “La doctora le dio la receta a la paciente.” (Female doctor, female patient)
  3. “El doctor le dio la receta a la paciente.” (Male doctor, female patient)
  4. “La doctora le dio la receta al paciente.” (Female doctor, male patient)

This way, the user has all the power to choose the translation that best fits the context, helping to avoid gender bias. While this is a big step forward made by Apple and USC, it’s still not perfect as machine translation still has its limits.

Why Human Translators Are Still Important

Even with innovative improvements like those from Apple and USC, machine translation can’t perform everything. Human translators, to this day, are still essential for getting the most accurate and culturally sensitive translations. They understand the context, tone, and cultural nuances that machines often don’t take into consideration.

At Universal Language Service, we know that human translation is the best and purest way to ensure accuracy and cultural competence. Our translators are experts not only in their primary languages, but also in the cultures and contexts they work with. This means they can avoid mistakes that machines usually make, especially when it comes to gender.

The Human Advantage

Human translators are superior as they translate the meaning of a sentence and not just the words within the sentence. They take into account the audience, the situation, and the subtle differences in language that might change how something is understood. This is beyond important in fields like healthcare and legal services, where even a small mistake could have serious consequences leading to misdiagnosis and poorly translated legal documents.

Our Commitment to Quality

At Universal Language Service, we’re committed to providing translations that are not only accurate but also culturally sensitive. Our human translators take the time to understand the full context of what they’re translating, ensuring that every word is chosen carefully and appropriately. This level of detail and care is something that machines simply can’t replicate.

We believe that language isn’t just a way of communicating with another human being, but a reflection of a country’s culture and identity. That’s why we prioritize human translation, so your message is conveyed exactly as you intend, without bias and with full respect for cultural differences.

Conclusion

While machine translation is getting better, it can’t replace the human touch. In a world where communication is more global than ever, it’s vital to make sure that translations are not only accurate but also culturally sensitive. At Universal Language Service, we’re dedicated to delivering high-quality translations that you can trust to be both precise and culturally aware.

Sources:

  1. ProZ.com. (2024, August 26). Apple and USC propose solution for gender bias in machine translation. ProZ.com Translation News. Retrieved from https://slator.com/apple-and-usc-propose-solution-for-gender-bias-in-machine-translation/
  2. Moirano, A. (2024, August 26). Apple and USC propose solution for gender bias in machine translation. Slator. Retrieved from https://slator.com/apple-and-usc-propose-solution-for-gender-bias-in-machine-translation/
Frequently Asked Questions
How does gender bias in machine translation affect everyday communication?

Gender bias in machine translation can lead to misunderstandings and reinforce stereotypes in everyday communication. For instance, when a machine translation system defaults to male pronouns or terms, it can misrepresent the intended meaning of a sentence, especially in languages that use gendered nouns and pronouns. This can be problematic in professional settings, such as in healthcare or legal translations, where accuracy is crucial. At Universal Language Service, we understand the importance of getting it right. That’s why we rely on skilled human translators who are aware of these nuances and can ensure that your message is communicated accurately, without gender bias.

What are the limitations of machine translation compared to human translation?

While machine translation is fast and convenient, it has significant limitations, particularly when it comes to context, cultural sensitivity, and gender neutrality. Machines often struggle with idiomatic expressions, tone, and cultural nuances, leading to translations that may be technically correct but lack the depth and accuracy that human translators provide. At Universal Language Service, our human translators bring a deep understanding of language and culture, ensuring that translations are not only accurate but also appropriate for the target audience. We believe that the human touch is essential for delivering high-quality, reliable translations.

How can businesses ensure their translations are culturally sensitive and accurate?

To ensure that your translations are both culturally sensitive and accurate, it’s essential to work with professional human translators who are not only fluent in the language but also deeply knowledgeable about the cultural context. At Universal Language Service, we prioritize cultural competence in every translation project. Our team of experienced translators takes the time to understand the cultural and linguistic nuances of your target audience, ensuring that your message resonates appropriately. By choosing Universal Language Service, you can trust that your translations will be handled with the utmost care and precision, free from the biases that can arise in machine translation.

Don’t miss out on the latest updates, industry insights, and exclusive offers from Universal Language Service, Inc. If you want to stay connected and be the first to know about the exciting developments in the interpreting and translation world, sign up for our newsletter today! Join our community of language enthusiasts, professionals, and individuals passionate about effective communication across cultures. Simply fill out the form below and start receiving valuable content directly to your inbox. Stay informed, stay empowered with Universal Language Service, Inc. newsletter!

UniversalLanguage Newsletter

Name(Required)
Email(Required)
Privacy(Required)